Pack your bags: we’re heading back to Beechwood! Prime Video finally revealed the cast for Season 2 of We Were Liars.
After the success of Season 1, Amazon renewed the series for a 2nd season, but no cast or release date was confirmed during that time. Now, the cast reveal of Season 2 has stirred up fresh excitement and anticipation among fans eager to return to the island.
Season 2 will be based on the prequel Family of Liars by E. Lockhart, where it will reveal the dark secrets of the Sinclair family, expanding the universe of the first book. With new faces of the Sinclair family, viewers will take a haunting look back at the summer of 1999, where the young Sinclair moms first navigated the betrayals and tragedies that would define their legacy.
Premise of Family of Liars
The Sinclair family returns to the windswept shores of their private Massachusetts island, where a restless ocean hides a history of sorrow and secrets. Centered on the volatile connection between a troubled heiress and an unpredictable boy, the story unfolds through a pivotal summer defined by unforgivable betrayal. This haunting return to Beechwood proves that the Sinclairs’ legacy has always been built on a foundation of lies and terrible mistakes.
Meet the cast of We Were Liars Season 2
Now that the stage is set for this 1999 prequel, it’s time to meet the actors stepping into the roles of the younger Sinclairs for We Were Liars Season 2.
Josh Dallas as Harris Sinclair
The Once Upon a Time alum joins the cast as the young, driven Harris Sinclair. While he remains the loyal husband and resilient worker fans recognize from Season 1, this prequel explores a more ambitious side of the patriarch. Despite his own growing success, Harris finds his vision for the future blocked by his older brother, setting the stage for a bitter family rivalry.
Peyton List as Tipper Taft Sinclair
As the family matriarch of a Kennedy-esque dynasty, Tipper is the ultimate image of old-money elegance, able to host a flawless dinner party while quietly pulling the strings behind her husband’s rise to power. However, when a sudden family crisis strikes, her composed facade cracks, revealing an icy temper and a collection of dirty secrets that could ruin the Sinclair name.
Parker Lapaine as Carrie Sinclair
The House of the Dragon star will take the role of the eldest Sinclair sister. In the summer of 1999, Carrie is sensitive, quick-witted, and yearning to be loved. She was seen as the Harvard-bound, obedient eldest daughter until her world changed with the arrival of a boy on Beechwood Island.
Elysia Roorbach as Penny Sinclair
The second daughter of the Sinclair family, Penny, was a charming and popular hopeless romantic during the summer of 1999. Eager to maintain her "Perfect Penny" facade, she carefully hides her struggles with body image and debilitating anxiety until someone finally sees beyond the mask she so desperately fights to keep in place.
Madison Wolfe as Bess Sinclair
At sixteen, aspiring songwriter Bess is desperate to escape her mother’s shadow by reinventing herself as an adventurer and seeking validation from the older college boys visiting the island. In her reckless quest to impress them, she makes a series of impulsive choices that will ultimately lead to a lifetime of regret.
Costa D’Angelo as Pfeff
A college student from New England, Pfeff is a mysterious, observant, and soulful young man whose wounded nature draws others in. Though he doesn't mean to, his arrival on Beechwood inevitably upends the Sinclair sisters' lives and shatters their carefully constructed world.
Can’t wait for the new season to drop? Get ahead of the mystery by picking up your copy of Family of Liars and We Were Liars today. Both are available at National Book Store in select branches nationwide.
Get the books at www.nationalbookstore.com, Shopee, Lazada, and TikTok Shop.
For more updates and to follow the latest winners, connect with National Book Store’s official social media accounts: @nationalbookstore on Instagram, Threads, and TikTok, and @nbsalert on Facebook, X, and YouTube.
